Wednesday, January 7, 2009

Playing the card................

This is a very sad case,” Gallagher told the newspaper. “I think it is particularly tragic that this girl had so little support that she wasn’t able to recognize any other option than what happened.” This pearl of wisdom and compassion comes from Port Angeles Washington Police Chief Gallagher who was commenting on the arrest of a 16 year old girl who " “put her baby face down into a toilet and allowed it to drown for several minutes until it died. Then she threw her son into the trash can outside in a plastic garbage bag.” They also popped her father for Meth and Felon in Possession of a firearm, but back to the statement made by the Chief. There is a common thread that repeats itself from time to time in the media when some young kid commits some incomprehensible crime. People want to give them a pass, remove accountability for their actions and lay it at the foot of the piss poor parent, or society, or poverty, or race, or any one of a countless litany of excuses.


Unlike Chief Gallagher I think it's particularly tragic that this heartless little bitch was able to snuff out the life she just brought in the world as if it were a goldfish she had grown tired of. The fact that her father was a scumbag has zero relevancy. What I find tragic is that she felt murder was preferable over a quick drive to the nearest hospital or police station to give the kid a chance in life, one that she probably got short changed on . I also find it tragic that an increasingly growing attitude in society is to excuse the ever more common atrocities committed by our children. From teen girls killing their newborns, to young inner city thugs who pick up a gun and spray bullets that often find more innocents as their target, society wants to give them a pass, or at least soften the edges of harsh reality by blaming it on some One or some Thing other than the killer.


As the story unfolds we will undoubtedly hear how this 16 year old killer came from an abusive background. The defense will lay the blame at the foot of the dope fiend father, or family services, or MTV, or video games, blame someone or something other than the killer. It's how we roll in this country. Avoiding accountability is a national past time. I believe it is also a contributing factor to the all to common incomprehensible acts committed by our young. It sends the message that you can do anything, and it's not your fault, just play the card.


Being poor, illiterate, abused, having absentee landlords for parents, growing up in the ghetto, being exposed to gang violence at an early age, and assorted other societal ills do contribute to how we turn out. I don't mean to discount any of those factors. They are real, and most people who commit crimes can point out at least one of those factors as contributing to the way they turned out. But once you cross the line, when you rape, or murder someone, those factors just become an excuse, they are no longer relevant. You lose the right to play the " blame it on someone else" card. You just become another scumbag taking up everyone else air.

12 comments:

  1. Reminded me of these lyrics:

    "You know I'm carrying with me
    Over twenty years of pity
    My whole personality
    Was formed by others, not me
    When I look back on my life
    One that's always filled with strife
    I rode down a bad course
    Nobody's fault but yours

    My stepfather always threw me right down the stairs
    So forgive me when I do the same thing to you
    I know it must seem like you're daddy never cares
    But if you knew what I've been through
    You'd do the same thing too

    Well I can't make a move
    Without draggin' all my baggage
    My father always cursed
    So forgive me for my language
    Please excuse me for yelling
    Pardon me for telling you to stop
    Selling to me your God in Heaven

    This is why I am the way that I am
    This is why I am the way that I am
    If I can keep this up for the rest of my days
    I may never have to take responsibility
    For my ways"

    Tourniquet - "Bearing Gruesome Cargo".

    Thanks for the rant, MM! You've been on a roll lately.

    ReplyDelete
  2. What she did was cruel and vicious. I don't care what her upbringing was like. No excuses for this she devil.

    ReplyDelete
  3. There are a few absolute wrongs in this world no matter what culture or moral background you come from. Murder is one of them.
    You are right on the mark, MM.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree w/ you, but the fact remains that if she would have aborted the little bugger nobody would have given a shite. What's the difference, really?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with what you wrote.
    To do such a thing one has to have a shred of decency or humanity missing from their soul.
    She needs to be locked up.

    ReplyDelete
  6. While I agree that this is an abominible act by this young girl, we also don't know the whole story. We don't know if she was forced to kill the child, we don't know if her own father was the baby's as well, we don't know the whole story. I do know that there has to be a slice of humanity missing from anyone who could hold a newborn baby in a toilet as you felt the life escape the teeny little body.
    The real tragedy is the justice system that will employ a defense attorney who will try to put all blame somewhere else, a prosecutor who will paint a picture of an evil young lady right in front of her face - and whatever the outcome, not an appropriate solution for the girl or justice for the life lost.
    Blah.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think the Chief needs to sit down and think about the difference between reason and excuse.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Leigh Anne, the difference is that we don't know when life begins.

    If she took a morning after pill (plan b) the morning after unprotected sex, and killed a developing oocyte, yeah, there's a big difference.

    If she had an abortion early in the first trimester, yeah, there is a big difference.

    If she had a partial birth abortion, there is less of a difference.

    Unless, of course, you believe, out of religious faith, life begins at conception. And you REALLY believe it. The vast majority of pro-lifers I talk to, when you get down to it, draw a distinction between the morning after pill and a third trimester abortion - which means they really don't believe life begins at conception.

    ReplyDelete
  9. DYSM
    What would you suggest I do? Is there someplace I can run out and buy a crystal ball that will give me the name and address of people about to commit heinous acts? Your statement that she is somehow too young to have a noition that sticking her childs face in a toilet until it's dead, tops the list of bullshit that Ive heard in recent memory. Stating the obvious is something I do often, making excuses and pointing a finger at society in general for the willfull acts of an individual is not something I do, ever. Not if the guilty party is me or someone else. She didnt want to be bothered, period, nothing you or I or all the social workers in the world can do anything about. Thats my opinion, and probably more stating of the obvious. Thanks for asking.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Since we're using lyrics let us try "Only A Lad" by Oingo Boingo:

    Only a lad
    He really couldnt help it
    Only a lad
    He didnt want to do it
    Only a lad
    Hes underprivileged and abused
    Perhaps a little bit confused

    Its not his fault that he cant believe
    Its not his fault that he cant behave
    Society made him go astray
    Perhaps if were nice hell go away
    Perhaps hell go away
    Hell go away

    I meet more inmates with sob stories about how they were abused or didn't get a "break" than I do the ones who own up and say "Yeah, I did it because I wanted to." Whenever I hear a public official making such an asinine statement I want to demand an immediate impeachment. Unless he's actually a defense attorney he doesn't need to be making such stupid statements. Defense attorneys are paid to mouth stupidity.
    This kid is obviously a budding sociopath and should be put away before she destroys anything else. Her whole family should be rounded up and shipped off for the betterment of mankind. Would the wholesale destruction of stupid people be considered genocide or eugenics?

    ReplyDelete
  11. I remember being 16 (wasn't that long ago, I'm a youngin) and I definitely knew what the notion of life was like.

    Homegirl needs to sit in a cell for a long, long time.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Well, MM, you're right. And then again, you are oh-so-very wrong. Would be so nice if the world were so cut and dried.

    She did an inexcusable thing. But I guarantee you she was not born a murderer. Life experience turned her into that. Sixteen years of no support, no parental guidance or affection - you apparently have no idea what that could do to a person.

    Add to that the fact that post-partum hormones play havoc with some women's psyches, and all kinds of reasons other than "she's a cold-hearted bitch" come to light.

    She needs to punished. More than anything, she needs to be helped. The human brain does not stop growing until about the age 23, and at 16, her brain is still growing at about the same rate as a toddler's. She needs intensive therapy and intervention to feed her brain all it has been deprived of over the years for her to stand a chance.

    Otherwise, you're right. Let's just write her off as a complete waste of humanity and move on.

    Til the next one.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.