Amanda Jax was a young Minnesota woman who died after another night of drinking too much. I say another, because this young woman had a couple of DUI's under her belt prior to her death. Now her mother is suing Amanda's friends for wrongful death. Jax mother said she hopes this lawsuit will prevent further deaths from binge drinking. She went on to say that she had no idea this kind of thing could happen. May I call ,Bullshit ?
The details of the events leading up to Jax death are pretty typical for a group of 20 - 22 year old college kids. They drank a whole lot of booze, Jax passed out and threw up, they took her home and discovered she had died at some point during the night. So the question I pose to all of you is this, Are her friends liable for her death?
I say absolutely not. This girl was a former nursing student who clearly had a drinking problem. She knew better than anyone else that she was drinking too much, it isn't her friends responsibility to monitor her, she was an adult. The mother of Amanda is understandably mourning the loss of her child, but lets be honest about her motivation behind this lawsuit. It has nothing to do with bringing awareness to an issue she claims she never knew existed, and it has everything to do with vindictiveness and bitterness. This is about a woman so hurt by the loss of her child, that she is hell bent on seeking retribution by ruining the lives of young people who were being irresponsible young people, exactly like her daughter was leading up to her death.
Guilt is a bitch, it will cause you to do things you might not normally do, add in an all consuming anger and a need to strike back, and you have what we have in this case. What Mrs. Jax is doing isn't justice, it's revenge, and it's just plain wrong. If her daughter had been one of the defendants rather than the victim, I guarantee you she wouldn't think this was a solid and fair lawsuit. Her contention that she was in the dark about binge drinking, is pretty thin. I doubt anyone in America hasn't heard of college kids drinking themselves to death, and Mrs Jax is being disingenuous in her claims of ignorance.
So let's just call this lawsuit what it is, revenge, pure and simple. The life of Amanda Jax mother is irrevocably changed for the worse. In her pain and anguish she is seeking the age old remedy to relieve it, revenge. But it wont bring back her child, it wont ease the pain or guilt. It will just serve to do further damage to more lives, and that ain't justice no matter how you slice it.
So what do you think?
I agree, 100%. We lost my husband's brother, while he was fighting a fire. The alarm didn't work right, the guy holding the hose didn't do what he should have, and the structure was empty. Did people mess up? yeah. Are there lawsuits pending? Yeah. Are we a part of them, nah. Screw that. No matter what gets done, Steve is gone. We can't get him back. Let it go.
ReplyDeleteRachel
Boy you are right on by saying guilt is a bitch. When my husband died I was so friggin mad at the doctor, I wanted to grab him by the throat, but that wouldn't have negated the years of drinking and smoking and bad lifestyle choices that led to his early death and my part in that as well. I sure as hell wasn't the poster girl for healthy living and still today I'm a mess in that regard.
ReplyDeleteFeel sorry though for anyone who loses a child they love. It's hell on earth but not right to blame someone else's child for that hell.
My brother took il suddenly and died on safari in Africa. I think the tour company was scared we would sue, but it never crossed our radar screen.
ReplyDeleteThe mom's point that she didn't know is bullshit and I don't think matters one iota. Young adults do stupid things and sometimes they die. Its just that simple. Of course if the deceased would have taken a bit more personal responsibility, we woudn't be having this conversation.
I agree with everyone else.
ReplyDeleteI completely agree with you MM. The mother of Jax is grieving and wants someone to blame for her daughter's death; so she is picking the easiest target-the girls that were with her daughter. Her daughter chose to drink that much alcohol; the friend's didn't force it down her throat! Hopefully this mother will come to her senses after a while; she needs some grief counseling!!
ReplyDelete